The Economic Mismatch: Flat Brokerage vs. Ad-Valorem MDR
The tension stems from a fundamental disconnect between how digital brokers make money and how payment processing fees are calculated:
- Fixed Revenue Model: Discount brokers like Zerodha, Groww, and Angel One operate primarily on a flat fee structure—typically charging ₹20 per executed order, irrespective of trade size (or ₹0 on equity delivery).
- Ad-Valorem Cost Model: Under the new 0.02% MDR framework, the payment gateway cost scales directly with the amount transferred into the account.
How the Math Breaks Down for a Discount Broker:
├── Deposit: ₹50,000 ──> MDR Cost: ₹10 (50% of gross brokerage revenue)
├── Deposit: ₹1,00,000 ──> MDR Cost: ₹20 (100% of gross brokerage revenue)
├── Deposit: ₹5,00,000 ──> MDR Cost: ₹100 (5x the maximum brokerage revenue earned)
└── Deposit: ₹15,00,000 ──> MDR Cost: ₹300 (15x the gross brokerage revenue earned)
If an active derivative or equity trader transfers ₹1,00,000 via UPI into their trading terminal and executes a single trade generating ₹20 in brokerage, the entire fee is swallowed by the UPI MDR.
The "Ghost Transfer" Problem
Compounding the problem is an operational reality unique to capital markets: fund additions do not equal trade executions.
Unlike an e-commerce shopping cart where payment occurs simultaneously with a profitable sale, investors frequently move money into trading accounts to:
- Maintain collateral margins against volatile open positions.
- Park liquidity in anticipation of market dips that may never materialize.
- Move funds back and forth between secondary bank accounts and trading ledgers.
Under the new regime, brokers will incur hard cash gateway expenses on fund transfers that generate zero brokerage, zero exchange fees, and zero interest income.
Founder Voices: Projections and Counter-Proposals
Both Nithin Kamath (Co-founder & CEO, Zerodha) and Ashish Kashyap (Founder & CEO, INDmoney) have laid out the stark operational consequences:
Industry LeaderPlatformCore Argument & Proposed Solution
Nithin Kamath
Zerodha
Concedes that payment rails carry server and operational costs and a fee was inevitable, but argues that a ₹300 cap is excessive for broking. He has proposed keeping the 0.02% rate but reducing the absolute ceiling to ₹5–₹10 per transaction.
Ashish Kashyap
INDmoney
Quantified the structural scale: An investment platform processing ₹200 Crore in daily UPI inflows will bleed approximately ₹11.52 Crore every year in MDR charges alone.